Art Review - February Issue - (Page 121) Warning : session_start : The session id contains invalid characters, valid characters are only a-z, A-Z and 0-9 in /mnt/data/www.nxtbook.com/fx/config_1.3/global.php on line 9 Warning : session_start : Cannot send session cache limiter - headers already sent output started at /mnt/data/www.nxtbook.com/fx/config_1.3/global.php:9 in /mnt/data/www.nxtbook.com/fx/config_1.3/global.php on line 9 Warning : Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by output started at /mnt/data/www.nxtbook.com/fx/config_1.3/global.php:9 in /mnt/data/www.nxtbook.com/fx/config_1.3/global.php on line 10 Why won’t Goth die? In Contemporary Gothic, Catherine Spooner performs a critical vivisection of the Goth subculture aesthetic to isolate the reasons why it eternally resurfaces in marginal and mainstream contemporary culture. Cutting through the subculture’s conventions and clichés, Spooner examines Goth’s roots in the gothic literary tradition while deftly deconstructing some of the more visible examples of Gothic pervasiveness. Spooner, a lecturer in English Literature at Lancaster University and author of the fascinating 2004 volume Fashioning Gothic Bodies, a history of the gothic fashion aesthetic, traces the flowering of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century horror literature through an interdisciplinary array of media. Unlike many of her peers, or the adolescents channelling their angst, destructive urges or feelings of alienation into Goth’s theatrically grotesque aesthetic, Spooner refuses to regard Goth as a peripheral or antisocial subcultural sect. She also rejects the commonly held idea that Goth acts as the dark underbelly to our light, bright pop culture. Instead, Spooner places contemporary Goth within a larger corporate context and explores the commoditization of the grotesque. She slices through the conceptual ligature underpinning London’s ghoulish themed pubs, a sampling of satanically suggestive alcohol advertising, the abject art of the Chapman brothers, Gregory Crewdson and Joel-Peter Witkin, as well as Buffy the Vampire Slayer, already popular fodder for academics. Smartly skimming well-worn territory like body modification and theories about how millennium anxiety accounts for gothic tendencies, Spooner instead looks at Goth as camp performance. Morbidity, aberrant sexuality, superstition and the appropriation of mass-media horror imagery are prominent themes in contemporary art, from Damien Hirst’s collection of flashing, nasty memento mori through to the new breed of emerging American artists seen in Saatchi’s USA Today collection at the Royal Academy. But Spooner looks past art to Goth’s dark influence on other, fluffier areas of culture. Her lucid probing into Goth’s historical, conceptual and commercial roots dispels much of its mystique as an aesthetic rebellion against mainstream imagery, without dismissing its inherent contradictions and its contemporary cultural importance. As with most subcultures, within their own ranks Goths are notoriously obsessed with defining and maintaining an internal hierarchy of authenticity. This subculture snobbery means that many of the sources Spooner examines lie on the outer edge of Goth. But as she persuasively argues, there can be no ‘authentic Goth’, because ‘Gothic possesses no original… Gothic takes the form of a series of revivals, each based on a fantasized idea of the previous one. As a form it has always been about fakery.’ Marilyn Manson and Buffy are therefore no less ‘authentic’ than the vampire cults that are as consumed with superficial fashion concerns as any other high school subgroup. Being confronted by the healthy, normal, banal subcutaneous layers that underlie Goth might disappoint many of its most dedicated followers, but Spooner also eloquently demonstrates that even commercially marketed and consumed Goth culture provides a vital intelligent, critical counterpoint to the pop, sparkle and giggle of mass popular culture. Ana Finel Honigman Contemporar y Gothic By Catherine Spooner FOCI/Reaktion Books, £12.95 / $19.95 p118-121 Books AR Feb07.indd 121 4/1/07 23:49:10 Warning : Unknown : The session id contains invalid characters, valid characters are only a-z, A-Z and 0-9 in Unknown on line 0 Warning : Unknown : Failed to write session data files . Please verify that the current setting of session.save_path is correct /var/lib/php/session in Unknown on line 0 Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Art Review - February Issue Art Review - February Issue Art Review - February Issue - (Page 1) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 2) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 3) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 4) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 5) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 6) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 7) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 8) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 9) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 10) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 11) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 12) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 13) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 14) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 15) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 16) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 17) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 18) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 19) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 20) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 21) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 22) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 23) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 24) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 25) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 26) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 27) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 28) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 29) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 30) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 31) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 32) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 33) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 34) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 35) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 36) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 37) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 38) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 39) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 40) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 41) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 42) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 43) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 44) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 45) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 46) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 47) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 48) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 49) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 50) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 51) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 52) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 53) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 54) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 55) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 56) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 57) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 58) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 59) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 60) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 61) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 62) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 63) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 64) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 65) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 66) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 67) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 68) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 69) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 70) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 71) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 72) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 73) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 74) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 75) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 76) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 77) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 78) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 79) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 80) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 81) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 82) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 83) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 84) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 85) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 86) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 87) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 88) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 89) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 90) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 91) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 92) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 93) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 94) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 95) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 96) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 97) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 98) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 99) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 100) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 101) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 102) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 103) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 104) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 105) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 106) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 107) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 108) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 109) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 110) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 111) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 112) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 113) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 114) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 115) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 116) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 117) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 118) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 119) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 120) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 121) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 122) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 123) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 124) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 125) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 126) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 127) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 128) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 129) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 130) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 131) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 132) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 133) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 134) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 135) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 136) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 137) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 138) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 139) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 140) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 141) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 142) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 143) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 144) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 145) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 146) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 147) Art Review - February Issue - (Page 148) http://www.nxtbookMEDIA.com
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.