Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 57

CRITIQUE

PLACES MADE BY SUBTRACTION
These qualities are comparable, perhaps,
to what Luis Barragán, in his Pritzker Prize
acceptance speech in 1980, described as
serenity ("the great and true antidote against
anguish and fear"), silence, and solitude. In
that speech Barragán also proclaimed the
importance of beauty to human life. Similarly,
Treib proclaims that in Japanese visual culture
(at least) "pairing the words 'austere' and
'beauty' is no anomaly" (p. 17). He proceeds
to argue his case by way of a dizzying array
of images of exemplary gardens, buildings,
earthworks, installations and excavations
from across the globe.
Fundamental to Treib's argument are the
complementary views that "[p]laces can be
made by subtraction as well as addition...at
times removal produces a far greater effect
than deposit" (p. 25) and an "austere garden
demands more from a visitor because, at
least to some degree, it defies our (Western)
received cultural norms of the garden as an

1

Eden" (p. 24). And, continuing his contrasts
with Western thinking, Treib argues that
designers "can also consider simplicity and
reduction...as the compression of many layers,
elements or textures into a single form" (p.
57), as in the Japanese Way of Tea. From
the viewer's perspective, in the context of
attending, Treib talks of deriving "more from
the participation of the reader" ...leaving...
"room for varied readings and interpretations
by the garden visitor" (p. 92).
Austere Gardens is a satisfying progression
from Must Landscape Mean? in that it
seeks to synthesize the intentions of the
designer and the reactions of the observer
in a complementary relationship. My
one complaint is that this is yet another
book without an index. When you've read
something that leaves an impression, you
want to be able to find it again. An index is
a gift to the reader, and it is (or should be)
another pleasure of print publications. But,
all-in-all, what we have here are two wideranging but easy-to-read volumes that should
be part of any contemplative landscape
architect's library.

2

THESE SLIM VOLUMES
ARE A WELCOME
REMINDER OF THE
HAPTIC (AND OTHER)
PLEASURES THAT CAN
STILL BE PROVOKED
BY WELL-PRESENTED
PRINT PUBLICATIONS.

ALAN TATE, PhD, PPLI, FCSLA, is Professor
and Head of Landscape Architecture at the
University of Manitoba and author of Great
City Parks (Second Edition: 2015).
alan.tate@umanitoba.ca

1 LIGHTNING FIELD 2 ZEN GARDEN
3 ALICE IN WONDERLAND 4 CAO XUEQIN
3

PHOTOS 1+2 AUSTERE GARDENS 3+4 THE MOST
BEAUTIFUL GARDENS EVER WRITTEN

4

SUMMER | ÉTÉ 2017 57



Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Landscapes - Summer 2017

TO BEGIN WITH | POUR COMMENCER
COLLABORATORS | COLLABORATEURS
PROLOGUE
ESSAY | ESSAI
Après le désordre vient le beau temps
A Fine Mess
Biophilic City
“I Am the Space Where I Am”
OPINION
Homo the Homogenizer? Do LAs Design Messy Terrain?
Waste-Less in Seattle: How Will This Look When It Gets Dirty?
Beaver the Disruptor Tolerating Disorder in the Heart of Vancouver
Messiness by Intention
CRITIQUE
@landtecanada Taking It With You
THE LAST WORD | LE MOT DE LA FIN
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - intro
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - cover1
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - cover2
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 3
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 4
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 5
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 6
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 7
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - TO BEGIN WITH | POUR COMMENCER
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 9
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - COLLABORATORS | COLLABORATEURS
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 11
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 12
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 13
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - PROLOGUE
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 15
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 16
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 17
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 18
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 19
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - ESSAY | ESSAI
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 21
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 22
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Après le désordre vient le beau temps
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 24
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 25
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - A Fine Mess
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 27
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 28
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 29
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 30
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Biophilic City
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 32
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 33
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - “I Am the Space Where I Am”
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 35
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 36
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 37
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 38
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 39
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - OPINION
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 41
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 42
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Homo the Homogenizer? Do LAs Design Messy Terrain?
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 44
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 45
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 46
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Waste-Less in Seattle: How Will This Look When It Gets Dirty?
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 48
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 49
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 50
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Beaver the Disruptor Tolerating Disorder in the Heart of Vancouver
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 52
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 53
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - Messiness by Intention
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 55
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - CRITIQUE
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 57
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - @landtecanada Taking It With You
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 59
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 60
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 61
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 62
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 63
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 64
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 65
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 66
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 67
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 68
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 69
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 70
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 71
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 72
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - 73
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - THE LAST WORD | LE MOT DE LA FIN
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - cover3
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - cover4
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus1
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus2
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus3
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus4
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus5
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus6
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus7
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus8
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus9
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus10
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus11
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus12
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus13
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus14
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus15
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus16
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus17
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus18
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus19
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus20
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus21
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus22
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus23
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus24
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus25
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus26
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus27
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus28
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus29
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus30
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus31
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus32
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus33
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus34
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus35
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus36
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus37
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus38
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus39
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus40
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus41
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus42
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus43
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus44
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus45
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus46
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus47
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus48
Landscapes - Summer 2017 - LPPlus49
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0319
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0219
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0119
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0418
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0318
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0218
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0118
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0417
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0317
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0217
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0117
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0416
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0316
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0216
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0116
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0415
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0315
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0215
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0115
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0414
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0314
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0214
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0114
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0413
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0313
http://www.nxtbook.com/naylor/CSLQ/CSLQ0213
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0113
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0412
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0312
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0212
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0112
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0411
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/naylor/CSLQ0311
http://www.nxtbookMEDIA.com