Seed Today - Q1 2008 - (Page 34) High Courts Again Uphold Patent Rights Without making any additional comments, the U.S. Supreme Court reaffirmed that patent laws apply to patented seeds. On January 7, the Supreme Court let stand a lower court ruling that punished Mississippi farmer Homan McFarling for reusing Monsanto’s patented Roundup Ready® soybeans. Monsanto sued McFarling in 1999 for violating its patents by planting biotech seeds that he saved from a previous year’s crop. The company won $375,000 in damages. McFarling purchased and planted Monsanto’s patented Roundup Ready soybean seeds in 1998. He used a portion of the subsequent crops as seed which he planted in 1999 and 2000. Lawyers for McFarling argued that patent law doesn’t allow Monsanto “to control the future use of seeds that were a natural product of the seeds that he had bought and planted.” But a district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit both sided with Monsanto. The Supreme Court let stand the appeals court’s ruling that second-generation seeds were “nearly identical copies” of Monsanto’s patented seeds. Canada’s Court Concurs In late November, the Federal Court of Canada issued a judgment against an Ontario farmer for patent infringement pertaining to Roundup Ready® soybeans. The Court awarded damages to Monsanto fixed at $8,800, equal to $160.00 per acre on 55 acres in question the farmer planted with saved Roundup Ready soybean seed. This judgment follows an earlier successful court judgment against another farmer in which the Court awarded Monsanto over $107,000 or $274.00 per acre on 392 acres of Roundup Ready soybeans planted without Monsanto’s permission. “We have a duty to protect our intellectual property and keep the playing field level for all growers who are purchasing Monsanto patented technologies,” says Trish Jordan, Monsanto’s Canadian spokesperson. “It is through the use of patents that we recoup our research investments, which allows us to continue to invest significant dollars in our research pipeline so that Canadian corn, soybean and canola growers will continue to have access to beneficial technologies in the future.” Monsanto is pursuing litigation with other parties in Ontario related to patent infringement. Response No. 341 34 First Quarter 2008 http://www.gustafson.com http://www.gustafson.com
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of Seed Today - Q1 2008 Seed Today - Q1 2008 Contents Editor’s Notes Cover Feature: Agrecol® Corporation Reed Barker, Ph.D. Cal/West Seeds Inc. Annual GM Use Report Bt Resistance Reported Camelina Tony Harper Gayle Jacklin According to ASTA Krauter Structures AOSCA AOSA/SCST GM and Greenhouse Gas Seed Associations Ad Index Seed Today - Q1 2008 Seed Today - Q1 2008 - (Page Intro) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Today - Q1 2008 (Page Cover1) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Today - Q1 2008 (Page Cover2) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Contents (Page 3) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Editor’s Notes (Page 4) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Editor’s Notes (Page 5) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Reed Barker, Ph.D. (Page 6) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Reed Barker, Ph.D. (Page 7) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Reed Barker, Ph.D. (Page 8) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Reed Barker, Ph.D. (Page 9) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Cal/West Seeds Inc. (Page 10) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Cal/West Seeds Inc. (Page 11) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Annual GM Use Report (Page 12) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Annual GM Use Report (Page 13) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Bt Resistance Reported (Page 14) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Bt Resistance Reported (Page 15) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Camelina (Page 16) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Camelina (Page 17) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Camelina (Page 18) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Camelina (Page 19) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Tony Harper (Page 20) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Gayle Jacklin (Page 21) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - According to ASTA (Page 22) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - According to ASTA (Page 23) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Krauter Structures (Page 24) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Krauter Structures (Page 25) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSCA (Page 26) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSCA (Page 27) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSCA (Page 28) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSCA (Page 29) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 30) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 31) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 32) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 33) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 34) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 35) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 36) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 37) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 38) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 39) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 40) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 41) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 42) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 43) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 44) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 45) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 46) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 47) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 48) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 49) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 50) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 51) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 52) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 53) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 54) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 55) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 56) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 57) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 58) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 59) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 60) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 61) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 62) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 63) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - AOSA/SCST (Page 64) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 65) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 66) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 67) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 68) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 69) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 70) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 71) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 72) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 73) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 74) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 75) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 76) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 77) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 78) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - GM and Greenhouse Gas (Page 79) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 80) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 81) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 82) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 83) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 84) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 85) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 86) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 87) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 88) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 89) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 90) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 91) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 92) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 93) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 94) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 95) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 96) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 97) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Seed Associations (Page 98) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Ad Index (Page 114) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Ad Index (Page Cover3) Seed Today - Q1 2008 - Ad Index (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.