MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - (Page 54) James Kovacs Loosen Tame Your Software Dependencies For More Flexible Apps ew would disagree that striving for a loosely coupled design is a bad thing. Unfortunately, the software we typically design is much more tightly coupled than we intend. How can you tell whether your design is tightly coupled? You can use a static analysis tool like NDepend to analyze your dependencies, but the easiest way to get a sense of the coupling in your application is to try to instantiate one of your classes in isolation. Pick a class from your business layer, such as an InvoiceService, and just copy its code into a new console project. Try to compile it. You’ll likely be missing some dependencies, such as an Invoice, InvoiceValidator, and so forth. Copy those classes to the console project and try again. You’ll likely discover other missing classes. When you are finally able to compile, you may find that you have a significant fraction of your codebase in the new project. It’s like pulling on a loose thread and watching your entire sweater fall apart. Every class is directly or indirectly coupled to every other class in your design. Making changes in this type of system is difficult at best because a change in any one class can have a ripple effect throughout the rest of the system. Now the point is not to eschew coupling completely, as that would be impossible. For instance: string name = “James Kovacs”; Up lihood of the System.String class changing in undesirable ways is very low, as is the likelihood that requirements will change in such a way that would necessitate modifying how I interact with System.String. So I am comfortable with that coupling. The point of this thought exercise is not to eliminate coupling but to be aware of it and to make sure you choose your couplings wisely. Let’s take another example of code often found in the data layer of many applications: SqlConnection conn = new SqlConnection(connectionString); This article uses the following technologies: .NET Framework This article discusses: What’s wrong with tightly coupled architectures ✥Testing and dependency woes ✥ Dependency inversion ✥ Dependency injection ✥ Code download available at: msdn.microsoft.com/msdnmag/code08.aspx James Kovacs is an independent architect, developer, trainer, and jack-of-all trades living in Calgary, Alberta, specializing in agile development using the .NET Framework. He is a Microsoft MVP for Solutions Architecture and received his master’s degree from Harvard University. James can be reached at jkovacs@post.harvard.edu or www.jameskovacs.com. I’ve coupled my code to the System.String class in the Microsoft® .NET Framework. Is that a bad thing? I would argue not. The like54 msdnmagazine http://msdn.microsoft.com/msdnmag/code08.aspx http://www.jameskovacs.com
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of MSDN Magazine - March 2008 MSDN Magazine - March 2008 Contents Toolbox CLR Inside Out Data Points Advanced Basics Office Space Introducing ASP.NET MVC Loosen Up CI Server Performance Office Development Test Run Security Briefs Extreme ASP.NET Foundations .NET Matters {End Bracket} MSDN Magazine - March 2008 MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - (Page Intro) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page Cover1) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page Cover2) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 1) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 2) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 3) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 4) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 5) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 6) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 7) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 8) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 9) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Contents (Page 10) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Toolbox (Page 11) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Toolbox (Page 12) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Toolbox (Page 13) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Toolbox (Page 14) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 15) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 16) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 17) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 18) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 19) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 20) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 21) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 22) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 23) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 24) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 25) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Data Points (Page 26) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 27) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 28) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 29) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 30) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 31) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Advanced Basics (Page 32) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 33) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 34) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 35) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 36) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 37) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 38) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 39) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 40) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Space (Page 41) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 42) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 43) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 44) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 45) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 46) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 47) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 48) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 49) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 50) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 51) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 52) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Introducing ASP.NET MVC (Page 53) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 54) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 55) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 56) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 57) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 58) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 59) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 60) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 61) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 62) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 63) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 64) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 65) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 66) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 67) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 68) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Loosen Up (Page 69) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 70) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 71) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 72) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 73) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 74) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 75) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 76) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 77) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 78) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 79) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - CI Server (Page 80) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 81) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 82) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 83) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 84) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 85) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 86) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 87) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Performance (Page 88) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 89) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 90) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 91) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 92) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 93) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 94) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 95) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Office Development (Page 96) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 97) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 98) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 99) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 100) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 101) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 102) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 103) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 104) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 105) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Test Run (Page 106) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Security Briefs (Page 107) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Security Briefs (Page 108) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Security Briefs (Page 109) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Security Briefs (Page 110) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 111) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 112) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 113) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 114) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 115) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 116) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 117) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Extreme ASP.NET (Page 118) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 119) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 120) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 121) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 122) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 123) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 124) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 125) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 126) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 127) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - Foundations (Page 128) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - .NET Matters (Page 129) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - .NET Matters (Page 130) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - .NET Matters (Page 131) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - {End Bracket} (Page 132) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - {End Bracket} (Page Cover3) MSDN Magazine - March 2008 - {End Bracket} (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.