MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - (Page 99) Testing SQL Stored Procedures Using LINQ Dr. JameS mccaffrey he need to test a program that accesses and manipulates a backend SQL Server® database is very common. In many such cases, the application interacts with the back-end data through the use of SQL stored procedures. In this type of scenario, you can think of the stored procedures as auxiliary methods of the system under test; and they must therefore be tested just like any other module in the system. Although there are several approaches you can take when testing SQL stored procedures, I have discovered that using LINQ dramatically simplifies test automation. In this month’s column, I show you how to test SQL stored procedures using LINQ—specifically, using the LINQ to SQL provider. I’ll assume you have intermediate level C# and SQL skills but no LINQ experience. If you examine Figure 1, you’ll see that I have written a small C# console application test harness that demonstrates the key activities you must perform when testing SQL stored procedures. I am testing a simple but representative stored procedure named usp_ DeleteMovie, which resides in a database of movie-related data named dbMovies. For each test case, I initialize a test bed database, call usp_DeleteMovie with a particular movie ID, and then check to see if the resulting state of dbMovies is correct. What is not apparent in Figure 1 is that I am using LINQ, which makes it easier to create my test harness than it is when I use ADO.NET and T-SQL. In the following sections, I will describe the dummy dbMovies database and usp_DeleteMovie stored procedure I am testing. I’ll also show you the code and explain the LINQ techniques used, and then I’ll explain how you can modify and extend my examples in order to meet your own needs. Before digging into the harness, let’s look at the sample database of the system under test so that you’ll understand the test automation. In a typical development environment, developers, testers, and database architects usually work with their own local copies of the back-end database. So, let’s assume that you have access to a SQL script that creates the current version of the database under test. A realistic database script would be long and complex, but the sample database creation script in Figure 2 is simple in order to keep the main concepts clear. My database is named dbMovies and contains two tables, tblMain and tblPrices. The tblMain table has a movie ID column (which is T the primary key), a title column, and a column that stores the duration of the movie (in minutes). The tblPrices table has a movie ID column and a column that stores the price of the movie. My database has three stored procedures: usp_DeleteMovie, usp_ GetMovieDataByPrice, and usp_GetMoviePrice. I preUsing LINQ dramatically cede the names of my stored simplifies test automation. procedures with usp_ to indicate that these are userIt is easier to create a test defined stored procedures harness using LINQ than it is as opposed to system stored using ADO.NET and T-SQL. procedures (sp_) or extended stored procedures (xp_). The points of note are that usp_DeleteMovie changes the state of the database but does not explicitly return a value; usp_GetMovieDataByPrice returns one or more SQL rowsets but does not change the state of dbMovies; and usp_GetMoviePrice returns two scalar values (one by a return value and one by an out-type parameter) but does not change database state. These represent the three most common situations when testing The System under Test Figure 1 Testing a Stored Procedure Using LINQ april2008 99
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of MSDN Magazine - April 2008 MSDN Magazine - April 2008 Contents Toolbox CLR Inside Out Basic Instincts Cutting Edge Foundations Test Run Service Station Windows with C++ Going Places { End Bracket } MSDN Magazine - April 2008 MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - (Page Intro) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page Cover1) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page Cover2) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 1) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 2) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 3) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 4) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 5) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 6) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 7) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 8) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 9) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Contents (Page 10) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 11) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 12) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 13) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 14) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 15) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Toolbox (Page 16) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 17) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 18) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 19) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 20) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 21) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 22) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 23) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - CLR Inside Out (Page 24) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 25) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 26) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 27) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 28) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 29) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 30) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 31) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 32) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 33) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Basic Instincts (Page 34) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 35) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 36) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 37) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 38) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 39) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 40) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 41) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 42) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 43) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 44) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 45) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Cutting Edge (Page 46) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 47) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 48) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 49) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 50) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 51) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 52) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 53) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 54) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 55) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 56) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 57) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 58) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 59) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 60) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 61) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 62) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 63) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 64) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 65) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 66) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 67) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 68) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 69) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 70) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 71) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 72) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 73) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 74) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 75) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 76) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 77) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 78) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 79) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 80) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 81) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 82) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 83) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 84) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 85) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 86) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 87) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 88) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 89) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 90) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 91) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 92) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 93) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 94) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 95) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 96) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 97) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Foundations (Page 98) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 99) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 100) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 101) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 102) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 103) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 104) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 105) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Test Run (Page 106) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 107) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 108) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 109) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 110) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 111) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 112) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 113) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Service Station (Page 114) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 115) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 116) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 117) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 118) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 119) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 120) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 121) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Windows with C++ (Page 122) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Going Places (Page 123) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Going Places (Page 124) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Going Places (Page 125) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Going Places (Page 126) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - Going Places (Page 127) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - { End Bracket } (Page 128) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - { End Bracket } (Page Cover3) MSDN Magazine - April 2008 - { End Bracket } (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.