TM - May 2008 - (Page 10) [human performance] by Harold D. Stolovich, Ph.D., CPT O O Beware Common Sense ne of the strongest admonitions pounded into young researchers is, “Don’t trust what common sense tells you.” So-called common sense is the greatest enemy of science. After all, in the name of common sense, people accepted the earth was flat with the sun moving around it. As performance professionals, we too must stand vigilant against the powerful sway of our own common sense, especially in unfamiliar work settings. Our training, experiences and logic can lead to grossly misleading interpretations of phenomena and events, resulting in inappropriate performance solutions. The following tale shows how easily perceptions can misguide us. Jessica’s Story Having recently graduated with a HR master’s degree, Jessica was excited about her new job as HR development manager at a multinational pharmaceutical firm. She was a young woman imbued with a strong work ethic and a powerful desire to help improve plant worker performance. Soon after she had settled into her new environment, she began reviewing her duties, which included training and performance support of manufacturing personnel. She noticed plant supervisors wandered about often shouting at assemblyline workers and packers. She was horrified at what appeared to be abusive language and tone. It became her mission to eliminate this behavior and improve supervisory performance. Fortunately, a mentor intervened before her zeal drove her to action. He advised Jessica to spend time working on the plant floor. At first, she found herself isolated. Then, taken under the wing of an experienced worker, she discovered a world far different from what she had initially perceived. Yes, supervisors strutted about shouting at workers and pointing out errors. However, her fellow workers explained, all of this behavior was simply to show management that supervisors took their jobs seriously. They were demonstrating conscientiousness. The assembly-line workers and packers clearly understood the rules of the game and paid no heed to supervisors’ noisemaking. Everything was just fine. A West African Experience Several years ago, our team designed and implemented a development program for high-potential new hires in a West African brewery. We patterned it on successful models tested in the • Managers judge performer progress based on objective measures. Reality: Manager is a father figure who protects subordinates in return for their respect and obedience. • Workers expected to be at work on time. Reality: Time is elastic. Family and clan responsibilities often supersede work requirements. • Selection of program managers and supervisors based on objective criteria. Reality: Selection subjective, often based on family ties, external pressures, political connections and clan obligations. Despite what appeared to be an unworkable situation — far removed from what common sense told us was right — adjustments and adaptations resulted in a wonderfully successful program. The team gathered infor- Our professional duties require us to lay aside preconceived notions, especially in unfamiliar settings. U.S., Europe and Asia. Yet, it soon became apparent our plan, which had made sense given the brewery’s needs and constraints, was untenable in this environment. • Trainers-mentors selected based on technical competence and ability to communicate. Reality: Trainers-mentors selected based on seniority, tribal compatibility and social status. • Feedback delivered based on performance. Reality: While feedback included discussing performance, delivery was based on recipients’ current family and life issues, and social status. • Best performers selected to demonstrate exemplary performance. Reality: Demonstrators all male since the high potentials were male, older than the persons being developed and culturally appropriate. About the Author Harold D. Stolovitch, Ph.D., is a principal of HSA Learning & Performance Solutions LLC and is an emeritus professor of instructional and performance technology at the Université de Montréal. He can be reached at editor@TalentMgt.com. mation, verified then reverified assumptions, made continuous changes and produced a viable program. Like scientific researchers, performance professionals undertake new endeavors with mental models and tools that generate visions of how things should work. While this good sense usually serves us well, it can become an enemy to performance. Our professional duties require us to lay aside preconceived notions, especially in unfamiliar settings. Our job is to observe, gather credible information and test-retest our perceptions before we draw conclusions or make performance improvement decisions. 10 May 2008 talent management magazine www.TalentMgt.com http://www.TalentMgt.com
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of TM - May 2008 Talent Management - May 2008 Editor's Letter Contents Human Performance Leading Edge Learning Connections Make the Connection: Effective Employee Evaluations Vacation: The Benefit Many Employees Don't Take The Four Pillars of Managing Performance Transform Talent With Deeper Skill Specialization Mentoring's Role in Succession Planning Graybar: Supporting a Long-Term View of Talent Management American Diabetes Association: On a Mission to Improve Employee Health Taking the Talent Pulse: What Drives High Potentials? American Systems Employees Earn a Piece of the Pie Advertisers’ Index Editorial Resources Full Potential TM - May 2008 TM - May 2008 - (Page Intro) TM - May 2008 - Talent Management - May 2008 (Page Cover1) TM - May 2008 - Talent Management - May 2008 (Page Cover2) TM - May 2008 - Talent Management - May 2008 (Page 1) TM - May 2008 - Talent Management - May 2008 (Page 2) TM - May 2008 - Talent Management - May 2008 (Page 3) TM - May 2008 - Editor's Letter (Page 4) TM - May 2008 - Editor's Letter (Page 5) TM - May 2008 - Contents (Page 6) TM - May 2008 - Contents (Page 7) TM - May 2008 - Contents (Page 8) TM - May 2008 - Contents (Page 9) TM - May 2008 - Human Performance (Page 10) TM - May 2008 - Human Performance (Page 11) TM - May 2008 - Leading Edge (Page 12) TM - May 2008 - Leading Edge (Page 13) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 14) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 15) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 16) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 17) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 18) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 19) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 20) TM - May 2008 - Learning Connections (Page 21) TM - May 2008 - Make the Connection: Effective Employee Evaluations (Page 22) TM - May 2008 - Make the Connection: Effective Employee Evaluations (Page 23) TM - May 2008 - Make the Connection: Effective Employee Evaluations (Page 24) TM - May 2008 - Make the Connection: Effective Employee Evaluations (Page 25) TM - May 2008 - Vacation: The Benefit Many Employees Don't Take (Page 26) TM - May 2008 - Vacation: The Benefit Many Employees Don't Take (Page 27) TM - May 2008 - Vacation: The Benefit Many Employees Don't Take (Page 28) TM - May 2008 - Vacation: The Benefit Many Employees Don't Take (Page 29) TM - May 2008 - The Four Pillars of Managing Performance (Page 30) TM - May 2008 - The Four Pillars of Managing Performance (Page 31) TM - May 2008 - The Four Pillars of Managing Performance (Page 32) TM - May 2008 - The Four Pillars of Managing Performance (Page 33) TM - May 2008 - Transform Talent With Deeper Skill Specialization (Page 34) TM - May 2008 - Transform Talent With Deeper Skill Specialization (Page 35) TM - May 2008 - Mentoring's Role in Succession Planning (Page 36) TM - May 2008 - Mentoring's Role in Succession Planning (Page 37) TM - May 2008 - Mentoring's Role in Succession Planning (Page 38) TM - May 2008 - Mentoring's Role in Succession Planning (Page 39) TM - May 2008 - Graybar: Supporting a Long-Term View of Talent Management (Page 40) TM - May 2008 - Graybar: Supporting a Long-Term View of Talent Management (Page 41) TM - May 2008 - American Diabetes Association: On a Mission to Improve Employee Health (Page 42) TM - May 2008 - American Diabetes Association: On a Mission to Improve Employee Health (Page 43) TM - May 2008 - Taking the Talent Pulse: What Drives High Potentials? (Page 44) TM - May 2008 - Taking the Talent Pulse: What Drives High Potentials? (Page 45) TM - May 2008 - Taking the Talent Pulse: What Drives High Potentials? (Page 46) TM - May 2008 - Taking the Talent Pulse: What Drives High Potentials? (Page 47) TM - May 2008 - American Systems Employees Earn a Piece of the Pie (Page 48) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page 49) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page 50) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page 51) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page 52) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page Cover3) TM - May 2008 - Editorial Resources (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.