EQ Magazine - June 2008 - (Page 36) VOCAL CORDS COMPING ON THE FLY by Paul Grundman If you are someone who tracks vocals using the “Record 30 vocal tracks/comp for three days straight” method, I urge you to stop being owned by your DAW. The first step is admitting you have a problem. It’s easy to get addicted. When I first got a DAW, I over-tracked so much I couldn’t remember the songs I was trying to produce. But, consider this: Back in the olden days, we had few tracks to work with. We came to a project with the knowledge that maybe we could have three tracks (or less) to capture “the” vocal performance. This kept everyone poised for action, and, in many cases, the singer rose to the occasion and nailed the track in one or two takes. Magic happened. We didn’t have the options of tuning software or unlimited tracks from which to comp a brilliant performance. So what’s the old-school lesson for the DAW age? To try something new that takes less time, and usually gets better results. THE CHALLENGE When you record a vocal performance 20 times in a row, you end up with takes where one line sounds soft, one sounds clearer, one is tired, one is more intense, and so on. Furthermore, you can only give so much direction before the artist is so exhausted, self-conscious, or so preoccupied by the repetition that singing becomes a cerebral performance. More times than not, a less-than-emotive performance will ultimately bring on the dreaded, “Um, I think maybe we should re-track the vocals” statement. And that statement often triggers something like, “Thank you, producer X—you’re fired!” THE “COMP ON THE FLY” SOLUTION Tell the vocalist that you’re going to record three tracks—a rehearsal, a serious take, and a “fun” track. Consider the routing in Figure 1, so you can quickly punch and comp all in the same window. Yes, you are committing yourself to recording a useable vocal in just three takes. So do not spend too much time getting sounds and not recording. Be quick, and get the sound as the vocalist is warming up. As soon as you have the three takes down, assemble them into one basic comp track (Figure 2). Leave the unused vocal parts alone—you may need to audition them later, or steal a snippet or two from them. Now, audition the single comp track for trouble spots, and punch in to correct anything you don’t like. I sometimes like to punch in an entire line to get the singer in the mood of the song, but if you’ve got a brilliant vocal with just one glitch, then just punch the offending word or phrase. You have just done what I call “comping on the fly.” It’s all about making the final vocal comp at the vocal session. You’re not faced legions of tracks to sort through and keep you up Fig. 1. How cool is it that all my vocal tracks are arranged in the same window? Fig. 2. The master comp track in all its glory. at night, the energy of the performer is not beaten down by numerous takes, and singers feel like they’ve delivered a more or less “real” performance. A WORD ABOUT CROSSFADES Well, there’s a little more effort involved in this process, as you want any punches and edits to sound natural. Just “butting up” two edit sections together isn’t always a good 36 EQ JUNE 2008 www.eqmag.com http://www.eqmag.com
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of EQ Magazine - June 2008 EQ Magazine - June 2008 Contents Talk Box Sounding Board 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos Tool Box Panic at the Disco Guitar Trax Bass Management Key Issues Drum Heads Vocal Cords Mix Bus Cheat Sheet Cakewalk Projects Apple Loops Utility SSL Duende Mini JBL LSR4326/PAK & LSR4312SP Holophone H3-D Creation Audio Labs MW1 Studio Tool Amp Modeler Roundup Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D Room with a Vu: Blues Tunes Studios, Silverlake, CA EQ Magazine - June 2008 EQ Magazine - June 2008 - EQ Magazine - June 2008 (Page Cover1) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - EQ Magazine - June 2008 (Page Cover2) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - EQ Magazine - June 2008 (Page 1) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Contents (Page 2) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Contents (Page 3) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Talk Box (Page 4) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Talk Box (Page 5) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Sounding Board (Page 6) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Sounding Board (Page 7) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 8) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 9) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 10) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 11) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 12) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - 3 Doors Down, Hard-Fi, Paul Manousos (Page 13) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Tool Box (Page 14) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Tool Box (Page 15) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Tool Box (Page 16) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Tool Box (Page 17) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 18) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 19) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 20) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 21) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 22) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 23) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 24) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 25) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 26) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Panic at the Disco (Page 27) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Guitar Trax (Page 28) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Guitar Trax (Page 29) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Bass Management (Page 30) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Bass Management (Page 31) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Key Issues (Page 32) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Key Issues (Page 33) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Drum Heads (Page 34) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Drum Heads (Page 35) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Vocal Cords (Page 36) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Vocal Cords (Page 37) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Mix Bus (Page 38) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Mix Bus (Page 39) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Cheat Sheet (Page 40) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Cheat Sheet (Page 41) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Cakewalk Projects (Page 42) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Cakewalk Projects (Page 43) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Apple Loops Utility (Page 44) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Apple Loops Utility (Page 45) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - SSL Duende Mini (Page 46) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - SSL Duende Mini (Page 47) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - JBL LSR4326/PAK & LSR4312SP (Page 48) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - JBL LSR4326/PAK & LSR4312SP (Page 49) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Holophone H3-D (Page 50) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Holophone H3-D (Page 51) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Creation Audio Labs MW1 Studio Tool (Page 52) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Creation Audio Labs MW1 Studio Tool (Page 53) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 54) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 55) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 56) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 57) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 58) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 59) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 60) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 61) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 62) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Amp Modeler Roundup (Page 63) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 64) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 65) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 66) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 67) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 68) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 69) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 70) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Eventide Timefactor, Electro-Harmonix Stereo Pedals, Korg Pandora PX5D (Page 71) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Room with a Vu: Blues Tunes Studios, Silverlake, CA (Page 72) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Room with a Vu: Blues Tunes Studios, Silverlake, CA (Page Cover3) EQ Magazine - June 2008 - Room with a Vu: Blues Tunes Studios, Silverlake, CA (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.