ProAudio Review - May 2008 - (Page 44) STUDIO | REVIEW by Tom Jung Primacoustic Recoil Stabilizer Nearfield Monitor Platform Thanks to physics, metaphysics, or both, the Recoils improve acoustic imaging, focus, and depth perception. When I first heard about the Recoil Stabilizer I thought, “Right—yet another foam pad for speakers,” but a friend of mine (whose ears I trust) told me it was the most exciting thing he saw demonstrated at AES in New York last fall. With that kind of approval, I ordered some for review—one per each of my three SLS PS8R ribbon monitors. FEATURES The Recoil Stabilizer is made from three basic components. First, a high-density urethane foam layer isolates the speaker from a meter-bridge or stand; this is designed to decouple the speaker and reduce vibrationborne resonance to the area below the speaker, like many other foam pads. Next is where things get different: a heavy laser-cut steel plate is added to the mix, sandwiched between the isolation layer and the next layer, a non-slip neoprene friction pad to keep the speaker from sliding around. The curved front 1/4-inch thick steel plate introduces substantial mass to the overall structure helping to stabilize the speaker. My own monitors have sat contentedly on solid speaker stands for many years without any concern of compromise, so I was naturally skeptical of the Recoil Stabilizers making any real improvement. When the Recoil Stabilizers first arrived, I placed them on my speaker stands and realized that the ribbon tweeters were now positioned too high at the listening position because of their total thickness — about three inches. One of many the things I like about the SLS ribbon speakers is the vertical dispersion is fairly narrow which keeps floor and ceiling reflections to a minimum. The Recoils are also available angled, so that more directional monitors can be focused in on the listening position. So, in my situation, I decided to build new stands at the correct height in order to make an effective “with/without” Recoil Stabilizer comparison. This is a little strange: with the Recoils, the speaker is no longer as steady due to the foam used for decoupling; however, it is apparent that the weight, mass and shape of the steel plate assembly is more than enough to compensate for the loss in rigidity. If I had to make a guess, I would choose rigidity over decoupling as a matter of importance, but as it turns out here, I would be wrong. A ratio of 4:1 speaker to Recoil Stabilizer weight is recommended; that is, the speaker should be no more than four times the weight of the Recoil Stabilizer, yet heavy enough for proper loading of the system. This ratio was apparently decided through extensive listening tests, and it is fairly obvious that the folks at Primacoustic have done their homework. I can remember a time when I would have rejected the idea of such a product, but it seems the older I get the more open I am to a new idea even if the physics do not totally make sense to me. IN USE After setting up the Recoil Stabilizers on my new speaker stands with the SLS monitors, it was listening time. The height of the speakers was now perfect but the stability still bothered me a little. I started off listening to a project I recorded with Warren Bernhardt on piano, Jay Anderson on bass and Peter Erskine on drums. The best way I can describe the piano sound is this: if it was a photograph, the focus just got sharper. Warren’s nine-foot Steinway sounded even more like it was in my room with me, almost like you could reach out and touch it. Jay Anderson’s acoustic bass went deeper without losing definition — more often than not acoustic bass extension can result in loss of pitch definition. Peter Erskine’s bass drum sounded fuller and fatter than I had heard it before, much more like it did in the room where we recorded. I always felt that I didn’t have quite enough in the mix, but now it sounds just right to me. Everything I played improved with the Recoil Stabilizers — it was clearer, offered sharper imaging and focus with more precise localization of instruments within the soundstage. Even depth perspective was better. SUMMARY Personally, I don’t think that the Recoil Stabilizers should work as well as they do — APPLICATIONS Studio, broadcast, post, mastering, and consumer/audiophile KEY FEATURES High-density urethane foam layer; a heavy laser-cut 1/4-inch steel plate; non-slip neoprene friction pad PRICE $100 to $150 list CONTACT Radial Engineering, Ltd. ☎ 604-942-1001 ➲ www.primacoustic.com 44 | ProAudio Review | May 2008 www.proaudioreview.com http://www.primacoustic.com http://www.proaudioreview.com
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.