ProAudio Review - August 2008 - (Page 58) Single Slice “Gamma Ray” | Beck by Strother Bullins SINGLE: "Gamma Ray" ALBUM: Modern Guilt (Interscope) DATE MASTERED: April to July 2008 at Gateway Mastering in Portland, Maine PRODUCERS: Beck and Danger Mouse ENGINEERS: Drew Brown and Darrell Thorp MIXERS: Darrell Thorp MASTERING ENGINEER: Bob Ludwig OTHER PROJECTS: One of our industry’s most prolific mastering engineers, Ludwig has put the finishing touches on albums for artists ranging from the Rolling Stones to Nirvana and Sly & the Family Stone to Coldplay. SINGLE SONGWRITER: Beck MASTERING MONITORS: Eggleston Works Ivy speakers (serial numbers 1 and 2) with bridged Cello Performance Mark II amplifiers and Transparent Audio Opus MM speaker cables MASTERING CONSOLE: Sound Performance Laboratory MMC-1 eight-channel analog surround console ANALOG PLAYBACK MACHINE: Ludwig’s “stock” Ampex ATR-102 1-inch analog SELECT MASTERING PROCESSOR: “one of many look-ahead limiters” such as the Junger, TC Electronics Finalizer, Sound Performance Laboratories Loudness Maximizer, or WAVES L1, L2, L3 and L316 ENGINEER’S DIARY Strother Bullins is a Contributing Editor for Pro Audio Review Truly renowned mastering engineer Bob Ludwig recently wrapped an atypically lengthy mastering session with avant-garde pop star Beck for Modern Guilt —the latest full-length album featuring the single, “Gamma Ray” —at his Gateway Mastering facility in Portland, Maine. “Gamma Ray”—a sneaky, slinky, low-key jam with a swinging surf-y ‘60s vibe —required Ludwig to be careful in how he left his fingerprints. “They liked their mixes a lot and they wanted it hot,” offers Ludwig of his only directive from the self-producing artist and co-producer, Danger Mouse. “Having worked with Beck before, I knew that his lyrics are extremely important to him. However, having said that, he doesn’t like them emphasized too much. I guess I’m trying to say that there’s a real fine line in between just right and too much; a little enhanced is way too much and a little back is way too back.” The subdued frequencies on the top end of the track could have lead some mastering engineers down the wrong path. “Upon first hearing it, your first impulse would be to brighten it up a bit,” explains Ludwig. In the past — on Beck’s previous albums and probably back to Odelay — Mastering Engineer Bob Ludwig I would do that and the response would be, ‘No, we like it better dull.’ But it turns out that it is all in service of the vocal. If you take many of the tracks on the new record and brighten them, it enhances things you don’t want to enhance: ticky little hi-hat effects, cymbals, and other things that may take your ear away from the emotion of the vocal.” For limiting, Ludwig looked at his arsenal of compression tools and picked what he knew would be best for the job … but he’s not telling. “There are many of these look-ahead limiters,” he explains. “They all sound different and they all are not created equal. Sometimes these various compressors are more euphonic with a certain song. That’s one of the secrets of a good mastering engineer: knowing — really well — the sound of all your tools. You hear something in your head and say, ‘I know just the sound for that.’ Mastering isn’t just making it loud. It’s finding that sweet spot between ‘competitively loud’ and most musically dynamic and satisfying … unless the A&R or the artist insists on crunching it to death, which is always terrible news.” 58 | ProAudio Review | August 2008 www.proaudioreview.com http://www.proaudioreview.com
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of ProAudio Review - August 2008 ProAudio Review - August 2008 Contents Publisher's Page Broadcast News and New Products Yamaha Pocketrak 2G Olympus LS-10 Linear PCM Recorder Bench Test Marantz PMD620 Flash Recorder TASCAM DR-1 Portable Digital Recorder Tips From The Pros: Location/Production Audio Prosumer Portables in a Pro World Studio News and New Products Apogee Ensemble Solid State Logic Duende Mini FireWire DSP Live News and New Products Avril Lavigne's The Best Damn Thing World Tour Behringer Eurolive B412DSP and B415DSP Active Loudspeakers Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List Contracting News and New Products Buyer's Guide Single Slice ProAudio Review - August 2008 ProAudio Review - August 2008 - ProAudio Review - August 2008 (Page Cover1) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - ProAudio Review - August 2008 (Page Cover2) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - ProAudio Review - August 2008 (Page 3) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Contents (Page 4) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Contents (Page 5) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Publisher's Page (Page 6) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Publisher's Page (Page 7) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Broadcast News and New Products (Page 8) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Broadcast News and New Products (Page 9) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Yamaha Pocketrak 2G (Page 10) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Yamaha Pocketrak 2G (Page 11) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Olympus LS-10 Linear PCM Recorder (Page 12) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Bench Test (Page 13) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Marantz PMD620 Flash Recorder (Page 14) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Marantz PMD620 Flash Recorder (Page 15) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - TASCAM DR-1 Portable Digital Recorder (Page 16) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - TASCAM DR-1 Portable Digital Recorder (Page 17) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - TASCAM DR-1 Portable Digital Recorder (Page 18) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - TASCAM DR-1 Portable Digital Recorder (Page 19) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Tips From The Pros: Location/Production Audio (Page 20) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Tips From The Pros: Location/Production Audio (Page 21) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Tips From The Pros: Location/Production Audio (Page 22) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Tips From The Pros: Location/Production Audio (Page 23) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Prosumer Portables in a Pro World (Page 24) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Prosumer Portables in a Pro World (Page 25) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Studio News and New Products (Page 26) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Studio News and New Products (Page 27) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 28) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 29) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 30) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 31) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 32) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Apogee Ensemble (Page 33) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Solid State Logic Duende Mini FireWire DSP (Page 34) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Solid State Logic Duende Mini FireWire DSP (Page 35) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Live News and New Products (Page 36) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Live News and New Products (Page 37) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Avril Lavigne's The Best Damn Thing World Tour (Page 38) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Avril Lavigne's The Best Damn Thing World Tour (Page 39) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Behringer Eurolive B412DSP and B415DSP Active Loudspeakers (Page 40) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Behringer Eurolive B412DSP and B415DSP Active Loudspeakers (Page 41) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Behringer Eurolive B412DSP and B415DSP Active Loudspeakers (Page 42) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Behringer Eurolive B412DSP and B415DSP Active Loudspeakers (Page 43) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 44) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 45) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 46) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 47) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 48) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Gear for FOH Engineers — A PAR Contributors’ Wish List (Page 49) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Contracting News and New Products (Page 50) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Contracting News and New Products (Page 51) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 52) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 53) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 54) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 55) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 56) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Buyer's Guide (Page 57) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Single Slice (Page 58) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Single Slice (Page Cover3) ProAudio Review - August 2008 - Single Slice (Page Cover4)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.