Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 43

Unit i

Case Study

43

uNIT I : CASE STuDY continued
Such logic, however, fails to recognize the fact that most Americans do not live in or around the suggested
introduction sites. Those people who are directly affected made up much of the 30 percent who did not want
wolves. This grassroots outcry is not just against the wolf. It rails against what many feel is just another way
for the government to extract more power from its citizens. By the end of 2010, the reintroduction had been
so successful that the wolves had multiplied well beyond the carrying capacity of Yellowstone and they had
started invading bordering ranchland. Wolves had begun to destroy livestock and other domestic animals
in large numbers, yet since they were still listed on the endangered species list, ranchers were powerless
to protect their animals. Thus, more than 80 years after the last wolf was removed from Yellowstone Park in
1926, Americans are embroiled in a raging debate over the wolves. In May 2011, the federal government
removed the gray wolf from the endangered species list, but only in eight states in the Northern Rockies
and Great Lakes region. That prompted an outcry of protest from environmental activists but freed affected
ranchers to remove wolves that were attacking their herds.
What do you believe? People favor or oppose wolf reintroduction on many grounds. Some
organizations are split over where they stand on this issue because of the details brought up on these
grounds. The Sierra Club does not favor wolf reintroduction in Idaho because of genetic reasons. The
Sierra Club has often championed the causes of wildlife. TABLE I-1 outlines the views of both sides of
this controversy.
You decide: Should wolves be reintroduced in other wild areas of the western United States?
On second thought, wolves were native to all of North America. Should they be reintroduced in
your community? Was the government right to remove the wolf from protected coverage in
limited area?

tABLE i-1 common arguments Both For and against Wolf reintroduction
Grounds

Favor

Oppose

Biological

Wolves serve the necessary role of
predator.
Wolves have shown an excellent success
rate when introduced to the wild.

As a predator, wolves kill ungulates,1
including cattle.
Captive animals often have a bad
record of success.
Wolves are surplus killers (they often
kill animals with no intention of using
them for food).

Economic

Wolves help maintain healthy ungulate
populations and should therefore be
beneficial to states that want to increase
trophy animals for hunters.

If wolves kill ungulates, then some
states, like Alaska, may limit the
number of available hunting permits.
In 1995 the Department of the
Interior (DOI) spent $6 million
on a project that resulted in the
reintroduction of 14 wolves, which
comes out to $207,000 per animal.
That does not include agency costs
for agencies involved in the program
but not in the DOI.
Continued



Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp

Contents
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - Cover1
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - Cover2
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - i
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - ii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - iii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - iv
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - v
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - Contents
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - vii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - viii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - ix
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - x
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xi
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xiii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xiv
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xv
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xvi
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xvii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xviii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - ixx
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xx
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xxi
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - xxii
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 1
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 2
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 3
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 4
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 5
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 6
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 7
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 8
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 9
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 10
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 11
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 12
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 13
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 14
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 15
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 16
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 17
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 18
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 19
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 20
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 21
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 22
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 23
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 24
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 25
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 26
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 27
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 28
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 29
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 30
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 31
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 32
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 33
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 34
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 35
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 36
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 37
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 38
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 39
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 40
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 41
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 42
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 43
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 44
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - 45
Managing Our Natural Resources, 6e, Camp - Cover4
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/autoservice5e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/bodystructures13e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/refrigerationactech8e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/medterminology8e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/naturalresources6e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/heavydutytruck6e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/sportsmedicine2017
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/agriculturalmechanics
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/introductoryhorticulture
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/basicrobotics
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/weldingprinciplesandapplications
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/delmars_electricity
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/modernlivestock_poultryproduction2016
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/introtoveterinaryscience_2016thirdedition
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/wildlifeandnaturalresourcemanagement_2016fourthedition
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/smallanimalcare_management_2016fourthedition
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/msoffice365_2016intro_illustrated
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/msoffice365_2016intermediate_illustrated
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/msoffice365_2016intermediate
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/msoffice365_2016intro
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/century21_10e
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/agriscience6
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/microsoftoffice2013_first
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/automotivetech6
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/dreamweaver_revealed
http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/ngsp/microsoftoffice2013_intro
http://www.nxtbookMEDIA.com