Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - (Page 35) Industrial-strength lighting Carefully evaluating different lighting schemes for an aerospace acoustical chamber leads to an optimal design solution. BY MIKE WATKINS, PE, LEED AP, Project Manager, The RMH Group, Lakewood, Colo. A lthough power, grounding, and controls take center stage in electrical design for the industrial environment, the challenges involved with lighting industrial spaces often are overlooked. These challenges include: • Making room and locations for the larger fixtures that typically are required for explosion-proof environments • Maintaining adequate lighting levels in wet or hose-down environments • Maintaining adequate lighting levels in high-vibration environments • Maintaining light fixtures in high-bay environments • Having instant illumination in high-bay environments while maintaining adequate lighting levels • Ensuring that light fixtures don’t disrupt the integrity of cleanroom environments • Identifying multiple suppliers who are able to supply design-compliant light fixtures when the owner’s contracting procedures require more than one manufacturer for materials • Providing energy-efficient lighting control schemes within industrial environments. A case study for an aerospace company illustrates how one team of lighting designers overcame a number of these challenges. The project entailed replacement of lighting inside a seven-story, Class 10,000 cleanroom, acoustical and vibration chamber, where aerospace equipment is tested, with a maintenance catwalk on each level. To add to the mix, the ground floor area inside the chamber was a Class 1, Division 2 hazardous environment. The existing lighting inside the chamber, designed in 1984, consisted of 15 400 W metal-halide floodlights centered on each of the three permanent walls and located 14 ft above the floor and 10 ft above each of the maintenance catwalks. The lighting was not uniform due to the shadows created by the catwalks and catwalk supports. In addition, the lighting levels did not meet cleanroom lighting standards of a 100 ft candles average. Instead, the lighting varied between 10 ft and 15 ft candles when measured in the middle of the chamber and less then 10 ft candles at the perimeter walls. In discussions with the user and the facility department, a number of lighting criteria were established: L This cleanroom space is explosion proof. Explosion-proof lighting must be used on the ground floor up to 14 ft above the floor. Photo courtesy The RMH Group Consulting-Specifying Engineer • NOVEMBER 2007 35
Table of Contents Feed for the Digital Edition of Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 Consulting-Specifying Engineer Contents Editor's Viewpoint Letters In The News M/E Roundtable Emergency Power for Healthcare 2007 Products of the Year Industrial-strength Lighting Hazardous HVAC Codes and Standards Management Report Jobs/Classifieds Specifier's Notebook On-Peak Performance Contents Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures Investing in Backup Power Systems Coes, Consultants, Manufacturers, and Standby Power Systems Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - (Page Intro) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Consulting-Specifying Engineer (Page Cover1) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Consulting-Specifying Engineer (Page Cover2) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Consulting-Specifying Engineer (Page 1) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Consulting-Specifying Engineer (Page 2) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Contents (Page 3) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Contents (Page 4) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Editor's Viewpoint (Page 5) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Editor's Viewpoint (Page 6) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Letters (Page 7) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Letters (Page 8) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - In The News (Page 9) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - In The News (Page 10) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 11) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 12) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 13) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 14) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 15) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 16) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - M/E Roundtable (Page 17) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 18) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 19) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 20) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 21) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 22) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 23) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 24) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Emergency Power for Healthcare (Page 25) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 26) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 27) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 28) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 29) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 30) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 31) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 32) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 33) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - 2007 Products of the Year (Page 34) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 35) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 36) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 37) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 38) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 39) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Industrial-strength Lighting (Page 40) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 41) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 42) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 43) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 44) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 45) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Hazardous HVAC (Page 46) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Codes and Standards (Page 47) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Codes and Standards (Page 48) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Codes and Standards (Page 49) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Codes and Standards (Page 50) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Management Report (Page 51) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Management Report (Page 52) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Jobs/Classifieds (Page 53) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Jobs/Classifieds (Page 54) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Jobs/Classifieds (Page 55) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Jobs/Classifieds (Page 56) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Jobs/Classifieds (Page 57) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Specifier's Notebook (Page 58) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Specifier's Notebook (Page Cover3) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Specifier's Notebook (Page Cover4) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - On-Peak Performance (Page S1) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - On-Peak Performance (Page S2) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Contents (Page S3) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S4) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S5) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S6) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S7) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S8) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S9) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Best Battery Selector in Engine Starting Applications (Page S10) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S11) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S12) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S13) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S14) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S15) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S16) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - NEC 708: Practical Impact on Backup Power Systems (Page S17) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures (Page S18) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures (Page S19) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures (Page S20) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures (Page S21) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Protecting Power: Specifying Outdoor Generator Enclosures (Page S22) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S23) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S24) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S25) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S26) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S27) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Investing in Backup Power Systems (Page S28) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Coes, Consultants, Manufacturers, and Standby Power Systems (Page S29) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Coes, Consultants, Manufacturers, and Standby Power Systems (Page S30) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Coes, Consultants, Manufacturers, and Standby Power Systems (Page S31) Consulting-Specifying Engineer - November 2007 - Coes, Consultants, Manufacturers, and Standby Power Systems (Page S32)
For optimal viewing of this digital publication, please enable JavaScript and then refresh the page. If you would like to try to load the digital publication without using Flash Player detection, please click here.