Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 69
threatened to bring into disrepute its own crucial effort to
rid campuses of sexual violence and harassment.
B
est known for its effects in promoting women's sports,
Title IX in fact prohibits all forms of sex-based discrimination-including sex-based violence-on campus. But court decisions have made it very difficult for individual targets of discrimination to enforce that prohibition.
And the Department of Education historically has not used
its enforcement authority aggressively against sexual harassment and violence.
All of that has changed in the Obama administration. In
administrative pronouncements issued in 2011 and 2014, the
department's Office for Civil Rights (OCR) emphasized and
elaborated on schools' obligations to prevent sexual harassment and assault. As of April 2015, the OCR was investigating more than 100 schools regarding their handling of cases
involving sexual violence.
Critics have leveled a growing bill of particulars against
the new enforcement efforts. In October 2014, twenty-eight
professors at Harvard Law School-representing positions
across the political spectrum-signed an open letter opposing Harvard University's new procedures for handling complaints of sexual misconduct. The faculty members alleged
that those new procedures, prompted by the Department of
Education's actions, "lack the most basic elements of fairness
and due process" and "are overwhelmingly stacked against
the accused."
These and other critics have focused, in particular,
on the procedures' requirement that university adjudicators apply only a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard
for determining whether an accused individual is responsible for sexual misconduct. Under that standard, which
generally applies in civil suits in the United States, the defendant is liable if the adjudicator determines that there
is a more than 50 percent chance that the defendant has
committed the act with which the plaintiff charged him.
That standard is a far less stringent one than the beyond-areasonable-doubt requirement that applies to criminal
prosecutions. Yale Law School professor Jed Rubenfeld argues that the application of the preponderance standard
makes "[m]istaken findings of guilt" a "real possibility."
Echoing the views of many administrators, he suggests
that campus procedures for handling sexual assault claims
should be designed to channel those claims to the criminal
justice system, where presumably expert investigators and
prosecutors can handle them properly.
Other critics have focused on perceived excesses in
universities' investigations of alleged harassing remarks by
faculty and students. Northwestern University's treatment
of professor Laura Kipnis has served as a prime example.
A cultural critic, Kipnis published a widely noted essay in
February 2015 arguing that universities' recent moves to
prohibit sexual relationships between faculty and their
adult students had gone too far. In the course of her essay,
Kipnis discussed a recent case at Northwestern in which
an undergraduate student accused a professor of unwanted sexual contact and charged that the university's sanction (denying the professor a raise and stripping him of his
named chair) was insufficient. Without naming any names
(though linking to a previous news article that named the
professor), Kipnis expressed skepticism of the student's
claim and called it "a mess" and "melodrama."
In response, two students claimed that Kipnis's essay
illegally retaliated against them for complaining about violations of Title IX. The university hired a law firm to investigate that complaint. As Michelle Goldberg of the Nation reported, Kipnis "was forced to submit to hours of questioning
about her essay and the ideas underlying it." Northwestern
closed the case only after Kipnis herself published a new essay about what she called her "Title IX Inquisition," which
provoked widespread criticism of the university's conduct.
A major, highly publicized
government enforcement
initiative on the high-profile
topic of campus sexual
violence was bound to lead to
an overreaction by university
bureaucrats pursuing
maximal risk aversion. The
Department of Education
should have seen that coming.
And in the most recent case to draw critics' attention,
the Louisiana State University fired an award-winning tenured professor of education for engaging in an alleged pattern of harassment. The professor, Teresa Buchanan, points
to a faculty report that "cited three 'notable' instances of
vulgarity on Buchanan's part: saying 'F*** no' repeatedly in
the presence of students, using a slang term for vagina that
implies cowardice and telling a joke that the quality of sex
gets worse the longer a relationship lasts." Buchanan has announced that she will sue the university, and the American
Association of University Professors has expressed support
for her case. LSU contends that Buchanan's offenses went
well beyond simply saying "Fuck no" in class, and the matter
will no doubt be settled in court.
T
he critics have a point about these cases. The Harvard sexual misconduct policies do raise troubling fairprocess concerns, Kipnis's "inquisition" was inapproWashington Monthly
69
Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Washington Monthly - September/October 2015
Contents
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - Cover1
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - Cover2
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 1
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 2
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 3
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 4
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 5
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 6
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 7
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 8
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - Contents
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 10
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 11
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 12
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 13
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 14
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 15
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 16
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 17
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 18
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 19
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 20
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 21
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 22
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 23
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 24
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 25
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 26
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 27
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 28
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 29
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 30
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 31
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 32
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 33
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 34
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 35
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 36
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 37
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 38
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 39
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 40
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 41
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 42
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 43
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 44
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 45
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 46
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 47
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 48
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 49
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 50
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 51
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 52
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 53
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 54
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 55
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 56
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 57
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 58
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 59
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 60
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 61
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 62
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 63
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 64
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 65
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 66
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 67
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 68
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 69
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 70
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 71
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 72
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 73
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 74
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 75
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 76
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 77
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 78
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 79
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 80
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 81
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 82
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 83
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 84
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 85
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 86
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 87
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 88
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 89
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 90
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 91
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 92
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 93
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 94
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 95
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 96
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 97
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 98
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 99
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 100
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 101
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 102
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 103
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 104
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 105
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 106
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 107
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 108
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 109
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 110
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 111
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 112
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 113
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 114
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 115
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 116
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 117
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 118
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 119
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 120
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 121
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 122
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 123
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - 124
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - Cover3
Washington Monthly - September/October 2015 - Cover4
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20230910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20220910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20210910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20200910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20190910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20180910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20160910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20150910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20140910
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/washingtonmonthly/20120910
https://www.nxtbookmedia.com