JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 560)
Hardy et al
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Volume 55, Number 5, December 15, 2010
censored from the 96-week analysis. Those placebo recipients
who had not reached a treatment failure endpoint were
followed through week 96 for descriptive purposes but were
not included in the efficacy analysis, as the studies became
noncomparative after unblinding.
Efficacy was assessed as the proportion of patients with
plasma HIV-1 RNA ,50 copies per milliliter at week 48 who
maintained virologic control through week 96. Virologic
control was stratified as follows: (1) those who maintained
,50 copies per milliliter through week 96; (2) those with
plasma HIV-1 RNAbetween 50 and 400 copies per milliliter at
week 96; and (3) those with HIV-1 RNA .400 copies per
milliliter at week 96 but who had not reached the criterion for
virologic failure (on study, not failed). For the week-96
analysis, this failure criterion was specified as a rise in plasma
HIV-1 RNA to at least 3 times the value at baseline.
Safety Analysis
This analysis includes all blinded data until EBT for study
patients according to their original randomization. It does not
include any open-label treatment data. Consistent with the
change in study analysis plan at EBT, patient data could
contribute to the efficacy analysis both before and after EBT;
however, for the safety analysis, only data collected while
patientswere receiving original blinded treatmentwere included.
Hence, the safety analysis comprises a wide range of blinded
exposure durations to maraviroc or placebo between week 48
and EBT. Safety data for both week 48 and EBT are presented.
Due to the considerable differences in the range of
exposures to blinded study therapy between the maraviroctreated
and placebo-treated patients (Fig. 1B), the safety analysis
examined both unadjusted and exposure-adjusted incidences of
all-cause adverse events, AIDS-defining events (CDC category
C), malignancies, and hepatic enzyme and function tests. Event
countswere adjusted to 100 years of subject exposure, and if the
same subject had more than 1 occurrence in the same event
category, only the most severe occurrence was considered.
Reported changes in hepatic transaminase and total bilirubin
testswere limited to the occurrence ofmoderate-to-severe events
(.3 3 ULN for transaminases and .1.5 3 ULN for total
bilirubin) irrespective of baseline grading. Of note,MOTIVATE
inclusion criteria allowed enrollment of otherwise eligible
patients with mild-to-moderate elevations of transaminases
(#5 3 ULN) or total bilirubin (#2.5 3 ULN).
Statistical Methods
Demographics and baseline characteristics were sum-
marized using descriptive statistics. Unless otherwise noted,
percentages are based on the total number of subjects initially
randomized to the 3 study arms. Median change from baseline
in CD4+
T-cell count at week 96 was calculated using the last
available observation on each subject.
The study was designed by the sponsor, Pfizer Global
Research and Development, with input from the study
investigators. Data were gathered by the study investigators
and the sponsor, with data summaries provided by an
independent statistician (Covance CAPS, Berkshire, United
Kingdom) from the Statistical Data Analysis Center to the data
and safety monitoring board for periodic review. All statistical
560 | www.jaids.com
analyses were carried out by the study sponsor according to
a predefined plan. One of the authors wrote the paper, with
extensive input from the study team. The study teamconfirms the
accuracy and completeness of the data and analysis as presented.
RESULTS
The combinedMOTIVATE 1 and 2 studies included 1049
randomized patients who received at least 1 dose of maraviroc
every day (n = 414),maraviroc twice a day (n = 426), or placebo
(n = 209). Patient demographic and baseline characteristicswere
similar across the 3 treatment groups (Table 1). Two-thirds of
enrolled patients received OBTs with 2 or fewer potentially
active antiretroviral agents, assessed by the overall regimen
susceptibility score.11
More than 40% of patients received
enfuvirtide as part of their OBT; 59% of this group were
receiving enfuvirtide for the first time. Less than 15% of subjects
in MOTIVATE received tipranavir as a new protease inhibitor.
The duration of study treatment exposure was sub-
stantially greater for the maraviroc-treated patients (median 73
weeks, range up to 135 weeks) compared with those receiving
placebo (median 20weeks, range up to 132weeks) at EBT (Fig.
1B). As expected, 47% of placebo patients had experienced
treatment failure or drug intolerance and rolled over to openlabel
maraviroc twice a day at EBT. In contrast, 58% of
maraviroc every day patients and 61%of maraviroc twice a day
patients had not experienced treatment failure or intolerance at
EBT and rolled over to open-label maraviroc twice a day.
Efficacy Analysis
For study subjects assigned to maraviroc twice a day,
whose treatment remained the same preweek and postweek 48,
41% had HIV-1 RNA ,50 copies per milliliter at week 96,
compared with 46% at week 48 (Fig. 2A). For those assigned
to maraviroc every day, for whom postweek 48 data included
TABLE 1. Demographics and Baseline Characteristics
Treated,
n = 1049
Mean age, yrs (range)
Female, n (%)
White, n (%)
Mean CD4+ cell
count, (cells/mm3)a
Mean HIV-1 RNA,
(log10 copies/mL)b
#2 active drugs in OBT, %c
Enfuvirtide in OBT, %
Enfuvirtide sensitive
and first use, %
Tipranavir in OBT, %
Placebo + OBT,
n = 209
MVC Every
Day + OBT,
n = 414
51 (12)
336 (81)
171
4.86
66.0
40.6
22.3
15.9
MVC Twice
a Day + OBT,
n = 426
46 (29–72) 46 (17–75) 46 (21–73)
24 (12)
178 (85)
171
44 (10)
363 (85)
167
4.86
66.0
43.5
28.0
13.9
4.85
69.7
42.7
26.0
14.8
MVC, maraviroc.
acalculated for each patient as the mean of up to two pre-dose assessments (screening
and baseline).
bcalculated for each patient as the mean of up to three pre-dose assessments
(screening, randomization, and baseline).
caccording to overall susceptibility score at screening. Includes all patients who
received at least one dose of study medication.
q 2010 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
http://www.jaids.com
Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page Intro)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page Cover1)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 558)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 559)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 560)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 561)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 562)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 563)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page 564)
JAIDS_55(5)558#564_RCI1AL4155 - (Page Cover4)
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/IJGC_SPV1ML4915
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/russian_nxtd
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_881012141221_GUY1AL4676
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/courology_eprint_201109
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/AJCVD_106401412_BIN1DX4559
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/DRUGS_716651677_BIN1DX4558
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/BPM_154202-215_BIN1DY4555
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/jaids_5813846_VHC1OL4381
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_923321327_GUY1AL4549
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_924410418_GUY1AL4537
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_88169-76_GUY1AL4535
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_922235-243_GUY1AL4536
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_924410418Article_GUY1AL4537
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_90S2118-118_GUY1AL4532
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/jaids_544394_397
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/aids_23121547_1556
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/jaids_555558_564
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/aids_24111667_1678
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/aids_24172743_2750
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/aids_24132019_2027
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_20110701_BMS1FY4018
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/courology_eprint_201106
https://www.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/transplantation_20110415_NOV1SL3521
http://europe.nxtbook.com/wolters/wolterskluwer/jto_591414-1423
http://europe.nxtbook.com/nxteu/wolterskluwer/amj_20110304_NOV1SL3203
http://europe.nxtbook.com/nxteu/wolterskluwer/transplantation_20110415_NOV1SL3115
http://europe.nxtbook.com/nxteu/wolterskluwer/drugsexpert
http://europe.nxtbook.com/nxteu/wolterskluwer/drugs
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/wolterskluwer/wolterskluwer_ubc
https://www.nxtbookmedia.com